There are Madonna albums with more hits (True Blue) and others with more critical acclaim (Ray of Light), but Erotica — the Queen of Pop’s fifth studio album — was a game-changing classic that found her at the peak of her powers as a pop provocateur. Released 30 years ago on Oct. 20, 1992 — in tandem with her scandalous Sex book, a coffee table tome featuring Isabella Rossellini, Naomi Campbell, Big Daddy Kane, Vanilla Ice, Tatiana von Fürstenberg and others — the LP showed that Madonna’s artistic ambitions were only getting bigger after the heights of 1989’s Like a Prayer. Enlisting “Vogue” producer Shep Pettibone and “Justify My Love” producer André Betts, she continued to push boundaries — and buttons — liberating her creativity as well as her sexuality.
The album was not as big of a hit as its predecessor, the blockbuster Like a Prayer, peaking at No. 2 on the Billboard 200, making it her first studio LP since her self-titled debut not to reach the pole position on that chart. And while four of its singles were top 40 hits on the Hot 100 – including the No. 3-peaking title track and the No. 7 hit “Deeper and Deeper” – some felt that was a disappointment compared to the No. 1 peaks reached by then-recent previous singles “This Used to Be My Playground,” “Justify My Love” and “Vogue.”
But 30 years later, it’s abundantly clear that Erotica paved the way for other pop divas — from Janet Jackson to Beyoncé to Christina Aguilera — who were willing to get their freak on. Here, we rank all 14 tracks on an iconic album that forever sexed-up pop music.
-
“Did You Do It?”
Playing like a bonus track, this was basically a hip-hop remix of “Waiting,” constructed over the very same beat with Betts jokingly rapping about whether he hit it with Madonna. It’s fun but ultimately forgettable filler on an album that didn’t need it. Listen here.
-
“Why’s It So Hard”
As great of a Madonna album as Erotica is, there are a couple of head-scratchers — and “Why’s It So Hard” is right at the top of the list. It’s a call to “love your sister, love your brother” set to a bass-heavy reggae groove that sounds as if it might have been inspired by Soul II Soul as much as Bob Marley. Still, there was a sexiness to the social consciousness. Listen here.
-
“Thief of Hearts”
Setting the ’60s girl-group charms of “Cherish,” “True Blue” and “Angel” to a slapping beat, Madonna takes you from the sock hop to the ballroom floor. It’s a moment of silly frivolity amidst the super-freakiness. Listen here.
-
“Words”
The typewriter-esque effects of this Pettibone-produced track, which were already gimmicky 30 years ago, haven’t aged well — you just don’t get the same sound from a MacBook Air keyboard. Still, the thumping deep-house beat speaks louder than words can when it comes to body-rocking action. Listen here.
-
“Secret Garden”
In retrospect, the final track on Erotica — with its jazzy A Tribe Called Quest vibes — was the perfect segue into the R&B and hip-hop exploration of 1994’s Bedtime Stories. With a moody groove that seduces you on the sly, this is one of those deep cuts for the diehards. Listen here.
-
“Fever”
Madonna has not done a ton of covers in her career — and why would she when she could rake in all those publishing royalties with so many of her own songs? But turning up the tempo — as well as the temperature — on this Peggy Lee classic, she radically reworked it into a torch-house track that could burn up the dance floor. Listen here.
-
“Waiting”
The after-hours horniness of waiting for that booty call —long before Grindr and Tinder hookups — is captured with that sexy sax and Madonna’s lustful vocal. Swirling and twirling with desire, it’s a panting panty-dropper. Listen here.
-
“Bye Bye Baby”
While there’s an S&M undercurrent flowing from the dance floor to the dungeon on Erotica, Madonna inflicts a different kind of pain on this killer kiss-off. The bitter coldness of this heartless breakup song is filtered through a computerized chirp that makes Madonna sound completely devoid of human emotion as she delivers a latex-booted kick to the curb. Listen here.
-
“Rain”
Image Credit: Courtesy Photo On its surface, the fourth North American single from Erotica — and its third biggest hit, reaching No. 14 on the Hot 100, behind the title track and “Deeper and Deeper” — can seem like a commercial concession to the mainstream from Madonna going underground. But if you look deeper, this hopelessly romantic ballad envisions a love in the age of AIDS that will “wash away my sorrow, take away my pain.”
-
“In This Life”
The specter of AIDS looms large over Erotica—the entire album is a defiant reclamation of sex positivity after the worst of the epidemic in the ’80s. But the disease was still killing many in the gay community that had helped Madonna become Madonna. This plaintive ballad is the emotional heart of Erotica, with the singer at her most poignantly personal — and pointedly political — shining a light on the AIDS crisis as one of the biggest pop stars on the planet. Listen here.
-
“Bad Girl”
The third single from Erotica should have been a bigger hit — it was Madonna’s first single not to reach the top 20 of the Hot 100 since 1983’s “Burning Up” (it peaked at No. 36). But there’s a melancholy beauty to the long walk of shame as the Material Girl slinks home after a night of bad behavior. Despite all of those temporary pleasures, she comes to the realization that “I’m not happy when I act this way.” Listen here.
-
“Where Life Begins”
Set to a jazzy, juicy groove with lyrics about the “finger-licking good” joys of cunnilingus that would make Colonel Sanders blush, “Where Life Begins” was to Erotica what “Head” was to Prince’s Dirty Mind — an ode to oral sex that, in a feminist twist, demanded equal time on the receiving end for the ladies. Listen here.
-
“Deeper and Deeper”
Image Credit: Courtesy Photo Although you can hear echoes of “Express Yourself” and “Rescue Me” — the latter being a Pettibone-produced hit from The Immaculate Collection — the second single from Erotica was a direct descendant of “Vogue.” And Madonna makes that very clear when she quotes from her 1990 smash toward the end of this deep-house dive. Bringing the dance-floor drama, complete with a flamenco breakdown, it hits the soulful sweet spot of her voice as she makes a powerful, pro-LGBTQ statement about loving who you love.
-
“Erotica”
Image Credit: Courtesy Photo If “Deeper and Deeper” played like a sequel to “Vogue,” then “Erotica” picked up right where “Justify My Love” left off — except this time it was Pettibone behind the boards instead of Betts. But the opener and first single of Erotica has an aural allure all its own, setting your dirtiest fantasies to a grimy groove. Going from sultry spoken word in the verses to a postcoital purr in the chorus, it’s the sound of sex — and sleaze — with Madonna introducing herself as Mistress Dita long before there was a Madame X. Hinting at the sonic adventurism that was to come on Ray of Light, it was about the boldest move she could have made at the height of her career.